Two Men, Two Pits and a Blog

Craycort Grills Cast-Iron Grates

Well it happened. We have grilled so much meat that our humble steel cooking grate has finally burned through. Except those portions of the grate which have narrowed significantly, but still hang on, courtesy of the many fiery sorties and the great thermal traumas inflicted there.  It was a good grate, by and by, but not a great grate. It had a couple of short comings – but at the end of the day, I guess we all do.  For one,  it didn’t last more than a few years. A larger gauge steel would have helped there. However, secondly, it was a steel grate, and meat tends to stick to steel unless they are oiled down before hand. And lastly, tho not that important I suppose, steel grates are challenged when it comes to making those aesthetically pleasing grill marks on your meat. It doesn’t really rank all that important I guess, but every pit keeper in the back of their mind is quietly hoping for a killer diamond hatch pattern on his steak. It just makes him feel good. At any rate, it was time for a new grate. And thanks to a fellow named Rolf Buerkle and a good idea he had once, I got one.

Enter Craycort Grills Cast-Iron GratesThese are some of the very best grates you will find on the market today. We absolutely love them! The modularcast-iron-grate-l grate we went with was designed by the aforementioned Rolf Buerkle of Craycort Grills, and is specially constructed for the 18 1/2 inch weber kettle grill. They come in any size Weber you have tho, so fear not. They also are excellent, they say, for big green eggs, and kamados joes. At any rate, it has been a grand experience thus far. Let me tell you about it.

Cast Iron Grate, Pre Seasoned, Non Stick Cooking Surface, Modular Fits 22.5″ Grills

The Pros: 

The Craycort customer service was pretty awesome right from the get go. Rolf himself contacted us, making sure we got everything we needed. And we did. Rolf seemed a pleasant, meat-eating fellow, in good humor, who at once appreciated not only our premeditated love for cast iron, but also our proclivity for winter grilling. He took care of us, for sure! He sent us one of his 18.5 inch cast iron grates as seen below.craycort grill

The grate that came in the mail was heavy. Like almost 12 pounds kind of heavy. A manly grate weight if ever there was one. It was well packaged too, not that it needed much protection, as the thing is built rather like a Sherman tank, but it was good to see it was pampered right from the factory. What we also appreciated is that it came already seasoned in soy oil. So it’s ready to start cooking with right out of the box. Even so, we let it cook a while on the pit, just in case, to burn off any residue that might have accidentally conspired there. The grate is also modular in design. Three pie pieces, if you will, which slip into the main cast iron ring. They are thick and heavy, and mean business right out of the box. You will be impressed.

craycort grateOf course the slick part, and the reason for going modular in the first place, is you can easily pluck out any section of the grate. This is a key feature for we patrons of the pit, who are forever and always tinkering with the coals; dumping more in along with varied chunks of smoke wood. There is a cast iron handle also sold separately for manipulating the hot grates, which we found quite handy. Or you could conceive your own tool, perhaps, to do the same job. Regardless, we instantly fell in love with the modular design of these grates.  It’s the same sort of setup for the 22.5 inch kettle grills, except those grates come with four sections, instead of three.  First impressions of the grate appealed to every manly fiber of our being. And if that were it, we probably would have been satisfied right there. But that wasn’t it. It got even better. One wordaccessories!

craycort grate2

Rolf was also kind enough to send us a cast iron hot plate/griddle insert. Buddy, now you’re speaking my love language! Simply pull out one of the grate sections and plunk this griddle in its place, and you’re off to the culinary races with such comestibles as: eggs, bacon, sausage, sandwiches, vegetables, and well, just about anything you would do on a griddle over the stove top. It gets even better still. These griddle inserts, we discovered, are also reversible. On the other side we found a series of raised, parallel edges, or ribs,  suitable for steaks or a panini or where ever your pit master instincts bring you. Very cool!  Craycort sells other accessories too, we found out, such as a vegetable wok, which is also modular and will slip right into place. There is a pizza stone too, which we might have to try some day.  Some good stuff – all of it made of durable cast iron. And we like that a lot. Back to these grates.


The pros keep chugging right along. And this next one falls into the aesthetic category – of what is pleasing to the eye.  If the grates are good and hot, cleaned and oiled down, you can amaze your friends and astound your family with the timeless pit keeper stamp of excellence – the sear mark. And cast iron grates excel at it. To assure the perfect sear mark, butter or oil your meat before you plunk it on the grate.


Remember those old black iron frying pans your grandma used to use? There is a reason grand mothers are always the best cooks in the family. They knew what to cast ironcook with! Cast iron well-cared for is not only something you can pass down to your children’s children, it is also supremely adept at evenly spreading heat and then retaining it there. Better yet, cast iron is one of the few things in the human condition that seems to get better with use. These grates will become more and more non-stick with each grilling session, just like grandma’s old cast iron frying pan. It’s not just something you cook with, it’s something, that with time, you are proud of. Something to last the ages. Say what you will, but that is no small thing.

The Cons:

For as great as these grates are, they are not without a downside. The dreaded beast of compromise surfaces once again. We found them to be a little pricey at around 70 to 80 bucks for a grate.  But the bright side is it should be the last grate you’ll ever need to buy, so, in the long run, you’re probably saving money. You will be hard pressed to burn through one of these grates. The other down side, and the only thing we can really knock on these grates is, being made of cast iron, they do and will have a tendency to rust if not cared for. But it is controllable with a wee bit of maintenance. If your cast iron grate is rusty, rest assured you have no one to blame but the pit master in the mirror. Craycort recommends you wipe the grate down in cooking oil before and after each cooking session. A good coating of oil is key to protecting cast iron, and especially these grates, which spend most of their lives out-of-doors.  Thus, let it be your habit, if you get one of these grates, to keep a bottle of peanut oil or the like handy, and simply make it part of your grilling process to keep the grate clean and wiped down in oil. It will take all of a minute out of your day and go a very long ways towards keeping this cast iron grate beautiful for a life time come.

In Summary:

We found the Craycort Grills 18.5 cast iron grate to be supremely rugged and well built. We cannot divine ever wearing this thing out, and we grill  a lot! The hot plate/griddle accessory looks to be equally as well- built, and we liked how it fit right in with the modular design of this grate. At first blush, the price point of the grate seemed a bit steep, but after considering how long it will last, which is basically for ever, well, the price seemed a trivial non-factor. We also loved its non-stick surface and heat retaining qualities of the cast iron, the latter which promotes better char marks. The only downside we found was its tendency to rust. They will require a little maintenance each cook. And that is no big deal really, for supreme grilling satisfaction. And the Craycourt customer service was amiable, friendly and prompt. Looks to be a good company sharing with the world an excellent product. That’s our review of it anyways.

So if you’re looking  to upgrade your kettle grill, or searching for a worthy birthday gift for your man, or resident pit keeper, he will be all smiles with one of these beautiful cast iron grates. You may even eat well that night too! Man!

Check them out along with other cast iron grilling products at: Craycort Grills

Or, since we are affiliates for amazon, you could go through our link here, and we might even get a small commission for our efforts. We sincerely appreciate your support. Thank you!

This site is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to


31 responses

  1. Nice review. Anyone who doesn’t know to look after cast iron doesn’t deserve it!… Grill on my friend.

    February 6, 2014 at 11:43 pm

  2. laurie27wsmith

    We expect to see some great cooking on your great grate Mate. We’ll wait. 🙂

    February 7, 2014 at 3:33 am

    • Always keen to whip out our poet sword! That’s why your great!

      Thanks Laurie. Be well!

      February 7, 2014 at 3:28 pm

      • laurie27wsmith

        Sorry, I couldn’t help it. Looking forward to seeing some grill marks on steaks. 🙂

        February 7, 2014 at 5:51 pm

  3. That is AWESOME! I may need to upgrade 😉

    February 7, 2014 at 10:00 am

  4. Debbie Spivey

    That’s really cool! I especially like the griddle insert. Shared with my own grill master! Very interesting!!

    February 7, 2014 at 11:26 am

    • I thought you guys might like this one. They make them to fit the Weber Performer too. Now you know what to get David for Christmas! He would probably love it.

      February 7, 2014 at 11:32 am

      • Debbie Spivey

        Yep. Thanks!! Happy Friday!!

        February 7, 2014 at 11:33 am

  5. I worked in the lawn and garden section at Sears for 5 years. Of course, BBQ grills were a part of my department. Because we were paid mostly on sales commissions, which I lead our department in sales every year, I took my products very seriously, and studied their pros and cons inside and out. So when a customer approached me, they knew they weren’t being fed a line of crap. When it came to the quality of a good BBQ, it began at the quality of the grates and went from there. If the grates were heavy-duty in comparison to the chicken-wire grates of the cheaper models, that was a very good indicator to the quality of the rest of the product. Bottom line, BBQ’s are a perfect example of you get exactly what you pay for.

    February 7, 2014 at 1:31 pm

    • As always, well said, Rick. Couldn’t agree with you more. It’s startling to consider how much money people might have saved had they spent the money right the first time. Not just with BBQ’s, but all matter of things.

      Thanks for the good comment!

      February 7, 2014 at 2:01 pm

  6. Wow! Just plain “Wow!” You know how I feel about cast iron, like others feel about Chanel. Checkin’ em out.

    February 7, 2014 at 3:22 pm

    • I hear ya Mrs. Deerslayer. And I couldn’t help but to think of you and your cast iron ninja skills when writing up this review. Its right up your alley!

      Take care!

      February 7, 2014 at 3:24 pm

  7. oh now – those are awesome!

    February 7, 2014 at 3:59 pm

    • Heck yes. They’re pretty slick, especially so the accessories.

      Thanks Kate! Happy Friday!

      February 7, 2014 at 4:01 pm

  8. I have been a fan of the cast iron grate for some time. A little more than two years ago, there was a deal on Groupon from a company called Mangrate. Knowing that the heavier the grate, the better the grilling especially for direct heat cooking like steaks and chops and burgers etc,, I bought a couple. They have been great. They sit on top of the Weber standard issue wire grille top. They get nice and hot and they make for beautiful grille marks. But most importantly, they cook great – very evenly. As a cook by time as a function of thickness griller, I can get perfect doneness every time.

    That said, I like the options and the look of the Craycort so they could be sitting on top of my second Weber very soon.

    Great post

    February 7, 2014 at 4:06 pm

    • Ah, thank you kindly, Joel. Always a treat when you chime in. I mean that. I look forward to it! Yes, there is very little not to love about cast iron grates. Long as you keep them oiled, they’re awesome.

      Bless ya, Joel! Have a good one!

      February 7, 2014 at 4:09 pm

      • I need to write you some grillin’ limericks! Have you been to Life Is A Limerick?

        February 7, 2014 at 8:15 pm

      • I have visited your site a few times, yes. It’s a hoot over there.

        Yes indeed, grilling limericks…I like the sound of that!

        February 7, 2014 at 8:18 pm

  9. Liz

    very pretty 🙂 About time you got an upgrade! If anyone is worth top-notch grill gear, it would be you.

    February 10, 2014 at 12:01 am

  10. Nice. I’ve been wanting those grates for awhile. Someday, they shall be mine. Oh yes, they shall. Nice write up.

    February 13, 2014 at 1:55 pm

  11. Pingback: Of Women and Fish: A Patron’s Shore Lunch | Patrons of the Pit

  12. Pingback: Quicker Days: How To Brine and Smoke Wild Duck | Patrons of the Pit

  13. Hello, nice to meet you and thank you for stopping by my miniscule blog. I see you are friends with John and Mary and I’ve been reading their past posts to catch up to date…wonderful and heartwarming blog. We are in need of a new grill, too, as ours has pretty much rusted out. Great review on the cast iron grates. I can so relate to the cold weather as we live in Northern Illinois. But we don’t have it in us to go out to grill in the cold, haha, you are very brave!

    January 16, 2016 at 9:05 am

    • Great to meet you too, Barbara! Yup, John and Mary’s blog. Not sure how I stumbled onto theirs, but I’m glad I did. Heartwarming indeed. Not to mention, I rather enjoy the old boy’s wit! So I try and always check in and see what’s going on down in Ecuador. And usually it’s quite a bit!

      Thank you kindly for stopping by our humble blog as well, and for spending a little time with us. Very kind of you. Yeah, we’re kind of nuts grilling out in the cold, but hey, we like to eat! Plus it always gives me something to write about.

      Bless ya Barbara , and have a great weekend!

      January 16, 2016 at 10:05 am

  14. Pingback: Vantage of a Pit Keeper: Pecan Smoked Bacon Cheese Burgers | Patrons of the Pit

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s